1. I'd like to ask
  2. 406 people in 166 cities are asking questions to 587 people
  1. Login
    Username
     
     Password
     
Click the "ask" button on the right to post your question.
Neil O'Brien Name: Neil O'Brien
Occupation: Chairman of IWantAReferendum.com campaign
Country: UK
Total Questions: 5
Total Answers: 5
What Yoosk members think about
Honest Yes No
Clear Yes No
Well informed Yes No
Inspiring Yes No
Consistent Yes No
Well intentioned Yes No
Answered Questions
  1. Londontowner asked Neil O'Brien: "Neil, would you support other referenda taking place at the same time- say on proportional representation, immigration and how to react to climate change? Like a kind of all encompassing 'Future of Britain'..." Show more »"Neil, would you support other referenda taking place at the same time- say on proportional representation, immigration and how to react to climate change? Like a kind of all encompassing 'Future of Britain' poll?" Show less »
  2. Neil O'Brien answers: "I don’t think you should hold multiple referendums at once – take one issue at a time for clarity, a better debate and to avoid manipulation."

  3. Macpherson asked Neil O'Brien: "Is the key motivation behind your campaign a desire to minimise the EU's strangehold over British legislation or simply an effort to give the people a democratic voice, whatever their decision?"
  4. Neil O'Brien answers: "Both. I would rather have a referendum and lose it than have no referendum at all. But I want people to be consulted.    More generally I believe in decentralization – power flowing back down from ..." Show more»"

    Both. I would rather have a referendum and lose it than have no referendum at all. But I want people to be consulted. 

     

    More generally I believe in decentralization – power flowing back down from the EU to the local and national level, and an increase in accountability and transparency not just in the EU but also more generally – for example the ever-growing number of quangos.

    "Show less«

  5. Macpherson asked Neil O'Brien: "How would you vote in a referendum and why?"
  6. Neil O'Brien answers: "I would vote no – (a) because the EU does not need more powers (b) to send a message that it needs reform and (c) because the process has been so dishonest.   Cast your mind back - this whole business..." Show more»"

    I would vote no – (a) because the EU does not need more powers (b) to send a message that it needs reform and (c) because the process has been so dishonest.

     

    Cast your mind back - this whole business started when the Irish voted against the Nice treaty in 2001. In response the leaders of the European Union promised they would start to make the EU more democratic, more transparent, and start handing powers back to the member states.

     

    But things quickly went off course. Although the leaders of the EU had signed up to these fine principles, and had even written them down in a grand document called the “Laeken Declaration”, the great majority did not actually believe in them in the slightest. 

     

    Instead, EU leaders appointed the federalist Valery Giscard d’Estaing to draw up an EU Constitution, which gave even more powers to the EU. Under the Constitution, everything from immigration to your electricity bill would become a subject for Brussels to decide on, by majority vote.

     

    When the Constitution was torpedoed by the French and Dutch, EU leaders simply dredged it up, gave it a fresh coat of paint, and had another go. I am not surprised the Treaty has been sunk again.

    "Show less«

  7. dominic asked Neil O'Brien: "

    - "A referendum was ruled out by the House of Commons, where does your campaign go from here?"

    "
  8. Neil O'Brien answers: "The whole question has been blown wide open again by the Irish no vote. We will be fighting to stop the verdict of the Irish people being circumvented by undemocratic means. The whole European political..." Show more»"

    The whole question has been blown wide open again by the Irish no vote. We will be fighting to stop the verdict of the Irish people being circumvented by undemocratic means. The whole European political class is involved in an effort to smear the Irish as ignorant, and to carry on as if nothing has happened.

     

    The French Europe Minister says, "I don't think you can say the treaty of Lisbon is dead even if the ratification process will be delayed.” The German Foreign Minister says, “We are sticking with our goal for it to come into force. The ratification process must continue.” What arrogance!

     

    Clearly, people who thought the treaty was dead, just because people had said no to it, were mistaken. The Irish no vote means nothing to the euro elite. We will be working to make sure the verdict of the Irish people is respected.

    "Show less«

  9. dominic asked Neil O'Brien: "What are your opinions on a potential referendum on Scottish Devolution?"
  10. Neil O'Brien answers: "It was right to have a referendum on devolution and it would be right to have a referendum if the executive were going to go push for independence.   Is the key motivation behind your campaign a desire..." Show more»"

    It was right to have a referendum on devolution and it would be right to have a referendum if the executive were going to go push for independence.

     

    Is the key motivation behind your campaign a desire to minimise the EU's strangehold over British legislation or simply an effort to give the people a democratic voice, whatever their decision?

    "Show less«

MORE ANSWERS!
Popular Questions
MORE QUESTIONS!
Recent Questions
MORE QUESTIONS!
What is Yoosk?
Yoosk is an interactive interview magazine
which enables you to participate in the
 news gathering process
by putting your
questions to politicians & celebrities

Six ways to do it

1.Put your questions directly to public figures
2.Get votes for them by mailing & bookmarking
3.Vote for other users’ questions
4.View answers & say what you think of them
5.Join a community of news enthusiasts
6.Submit your own ideas for interview features

Editors, reporters and bloggers
Use our software to set up your own Yoosk
Use our widget to collect your users’ questions

Public figures
Get closer to constituents, fans and customers
Answer their questions directly to webcam