Answers
  1. itsmattsmith asked David Miliband: "You recently said "the politics is as important as the military" and that success will be measured by the number of Afghans living peacefully within the constitution. What political strategy for Afghanistan..." Show more »"You recently said "the politics is as important as the military" and that success will be measured by the number of Afghans living peacefully within the constitution. What political strategy for Afghanistan toward state-building and away from tribally oriented politics is the UK Government pursuing? Does it extend beyond Karzai's fraudulent re-election?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. Tahera N. asked David Miliband: "Do you think President Hamid Karzi will be able to provide  a stable situation in Afghanistan with his new cabinet? Mr President H.Karzi has possessed the president chair through corruption; do you think..." Show more »"Do you think President Hamid Karzi will be able to provide  a stable situation in Afghanistan with his new cabinet? Mr President H.Karzi has possessed the president chair through corruption; do you think he will be able to eliminate corrupption from the country itself? Do you think Mr Karzi has education, health, women equal rights and Poverty on his top agenda and how serious he is on these issues?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. Sania asked David Miliband: "Sir,Why oo you think that war is the only solution of problems in Afganistan and to control Talibans when it seems in-effective until now?Why you do not consider table talks with Talibans and people of..." Show more »"Sir,Why oo you think that war is the only solution of problems in Afganistan and to control Talibans when it seems in-effective until now?Why you do not consider table talks with Talibans and people of Afghanistan which may be more effective to control these issues?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. Naim asked David Miliband: "Dear Sir Are you considering any military action inside Pakistan soil as the real nest and the root of Alqada laying there rather than villages of Afghanistan. Also are you monitoring the the money ..." Show more »"Dear Sir Are you considering any military action inside Pakistan soil as the real nest and the root of Alqada laying there rather than villages of Afghanistan. Also are you monitoring the the money you are giving to Pakistani military and Pakistan ISI to make sure that the money is not redirected to fund Alqa da and Takiban?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. faridallime asked David Miliband: "What measures are being  taken to tackel the issue of corruption within the afghan government?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. Sarahwvon asked David Miliband: "Why is the perspective of Afghan women not being addressed in this conference? A report in the Associated Press of Pakistan highlights the potential key contributions that Afghan women could make to these..." Show more »"Why is the perspective of Afghan women not being addressed in this conference? A report in the Associated Press of Pakistan highlights the potential key contributions that Afghan women could make to these discussions at
    http://www.app.com.pk/en_/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=95117&Itemid=2http://www.app.com.pk/en_/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=95117&Itemid=2" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "click 'play' to view."

  1. lydiap asked David Miliband: "Afghanistan is the world’s second leading recipient of humanitarian aid, yet $185 million of the UN’s Humanitarian Action Plan remained unfunded in 2009 (the UK contributing only 1.5% of the total funds..." Show more »"
    Afghanistan is the world’s second leading recipient of humanitarian aid, yet $185 million of the UN’s Humanitarian Action Plan remained unfunded in 2009 (the UK contributing only 1.5% of the total funds received) and many NGOs have complained that aid is being provided according to the military’s priorities, linked to support for counter-insurgency operations, and not on the basis of humanitarian need.
    How will the UK government ensure an adequate balance between supporting provision of urgent life-saving humanitarian assistance, in accordance with their international commitments to provide humanitarian funding on the basis of assessed need, and their agenda to support the development of a viable state and  security?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. English asked David Miliband: "Why don't we buy the opium instead of burning it? There is a world shortage of medical opium. Buying it from Afghan farmer would establish good relations rather than the opposite caused by current strategy..." Show more »"Why don't we buy the opium instead of burning it? There is a world shortage of medical opium. Buying it from Afghan farmer would establish good relations rather than the opposite caused by current strategy of torching the only crop that grows really well there. Also ex O farmers go and join taliban. Plus illegal trade also funts taliban." Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. earose asked David Miliband: "How has prosecution of the war on terror affected Britain's relationship with the U.S.?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. Poppy Jr asked David Miliband: " Since the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is the icon country of the Muslim Sunnis of the world and that is also the same religion of Talibans. Is there any plan to allow the saudi government to play a role ..." Show more »" Since the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is the icon country of the Muslim Sunnis of the world and that is also the same religion of Talibans. Is there any plan to allow the saudi government to play a role in a reconciliation inside Afghanistan>>let us say the same way Egypt is trying now to arrange reconciliation between Hamas and the Palestinian Authority?
    Do you believe that fighting to the end is the only way to solve Afghanistan problems?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. timlongs asked David Miliband: "Do you think it is a little hypocritical that we are trying to enforce democracy in Afghanistan by weakening ours in going into war there?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. Flo es Tsai asked David Miliband: "Poverty is a huge problem in Afghanistan and contributes to the situation. We hear a lot about the UK's military plans and objectives in Afghanistan, but hear less and less about development plans and..." Show more »"Poverty is a huge problem in Afghanistan and contributes to the situation. We hear a lot about the UK's military plans and objectives in Afghanistan, but hear less and less about development plans and objectives. What is the situation? " Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Minister of State Ivan Lewis answers this question on behalf of David Miliband."

  1. roneshdhawra asked David Miliband: "The Taliban forces seem to have now moved from destabilizing Afghanistan and into Pakistan. What is the UK's plans in this regard? Are the allies going to slowly move into Pakistan eventually?"
  2. David Miliband answer: " Minister of State Ivan Lewis answers this question on behalf of Foreign Secretary David Miliband."

  1. Victor Raica asked David Miliband: "1. When will the Islamic ideology and laws that the terrorists use to justify their atrocities be fully analyzed and discussed by the the people in charge, both in the UK and elsewhere? 2. Is it conceivable..." Show more »"1. When will the Islamic ideology and laws that the terrorists use to justify their atrocities be fully analyzed and discussed by the the people in charge, both in the UK and elsewhere? 2. Is it conceivable that failure to discuss the terrorists' tactics and strategy (which might be derived, in part, from holy texts and religious stories) can not only cause loss of life among coalition soldiers, but also lead to a perpetual war against terrorists in Afghanistan - since the ideology that creates new ones is not even discussed, let alone combatted with the enlightened ideas that lie at the heart of Western civilization?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Minister of State Ivan Lewis answers this question on behalf of Foreign Secretary David Miliband."

  1. Rana.J asked David Miliband: "During Afghanistan Conference, a side meeting on Yemen will be held. I am a Yemeni student in the UK and have been in touch with other Yemeni youth inside and outside the country to voice out our concerns...." Show more »"During Afghanistan Conference, a side meeting on Yemen will be held. I am a Yemeni student in the UK and have been in touch with other Yemeni youth inside and outside the country to voice out our concerns. The group has launched this website http://www.resonateyemen.org/ to allow Yemeni youth to do so. The website is meant to focus the topic of discussion on counter-terrorism, because many speculate the Yemen-London meeting will be about that. We would like to summarize the responses and make them heard in the meeting somehow. Would that be possible?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: " Minister of State Ivan Lewis answers this question on behalf of Foreign Secretary David Miliband."

  1. mike asked David Miliband: "What constitutes victory in Afghanistan?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. hollyy asked David Miliband: "Do you think the Government should do anything to increase the British publics awareness of poverty in Afghanistan, and what is being done to help? Or are we only supposed to be interested in the military..." Show more »"Do you think the Government should do anything to increase the British publics awareness of poverty in Afghanistan, and what is being done to help? Or are we only supposed to be interested in the military campaign?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. m.j.davis asked David Miliband: "Will you be listening to the Russians before and during the conference? They might not have had a legitimate reason to invade but it doesn't make the lessons they learnt any less relevant, does it?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. bridget asked David Miliband: "Do you believe that the British public are behind the government in its objectives on Afghanistan?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. shream2005 asked David Miliband: "لماذا نفذت المملكة المتحدة البند الخاص في وعد بلفور و الذي ينص على اقامة دولة يهودية في فلسطين و لكن لم تنفذ البند الثاني في نفس الوعد و هو عدم المساس باحقوق المدنية للشعب الفلسطيني في فلسطين حيث قامت..." Show more »"

    لماذا نفذت المملكة المتحدة البند الخاص في وعد بلفور و الذي ينص على اقامة دولة يهودية في فلسطين و لكن لم تنفذ البند الثاني في نفس الوعد و هو عدم المساس باحقوق المدنية للشعب الفلسطيني في فلسطين حيث قامت اسرائيل بتهجير ثلثي السكان و محو الاف القرى و هدم البيوت و قلع الاشجار  . . . الخ

    هل السبب في ذلك سيطرت الحركة الصهيونية على القوى السياسية في دول اوروبة الغربية و امريكا ام ضعف الجانب العربي و انعدام وزنهم السياسي لدى تلك الدول !

    ارجو ان يكون الجواب منطقي و واقعي و مقنع و ليس اعلامي و شكراً

    عقيد متقاعد : احمد محمود دره

    هاتف ارضي : 5345519 6 00962
    هاتف نقال :  6366605 79 00962

    " Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. meelad2003 asked David Miliband: "السيد وزير الخارجيه  الا تعتقد انه يجب على بريطانيا والاتحاد الاوربي اعادة النظر في دعمها المطلق لاسرائيل على الرغم من مسلسل الجرائم التي ترتكبها اسرائيل وان هاذا الدعم يولد كراهيه للموقف االبريطانيا..." Show more »"السيد وزير الخارجيه
     الا تعتقد انه يجب على بريطانيا والاتحاد الاوربي اعادة النظر في دعمها المطلق لاسرائيل على الرغم من مسلسل الجرائم التي ترتكبها اسرائيل وان هاذا الدعم يولد كراهيه للموقف االبريطانيا والنظر اليها على انها تتحمل المسؤليه التاريخيه عما يتعرض له الشعب الفلسطيني بسبب وعد بالفور؟" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. barw67 asked David Miliband: "

    هل صحيح ما يقال بان الاردن لا زالت تحت الوصاية البريطانيه وانه لا يستطيع ان يتصرف بثرواته الطبيعيه الاستراتيجيه كالنفط الا بعد انتهاء الوصايه في عام 2010 مع جزيل الشكر

    "
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. anabulsi10 asked David Miliband: "السيد وزير خارجية بريطانيا المحترم متى ستعترف بريطانيا بخطأها التاريخي بحق الشعب الفلسطيني حين أصدرت وعد بلفور ومنحت من خلاله وطناً قومياً لليهود على أرض فلسطين , وبالتالي تتحمل تبعات هذا القرار أدبياً..." Show more »"

    السيد وزير خارجية بريطانيا المحترم
    متى ستعترف بريطانيا بخطأها التاريخي بحق الشعب الفلسطيني حين أصدرت وعد بلفور ومنحت من خلاله وطناً قومياً لليهود على أرض فلسطين , وبالتالي تتحمل تبعات هذا القرار
    أدبياً وقانونياً ومادياً وتصحح ما قامت به ؟

    " Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. hamzehsh1 asked David Miliband: "Mr.David Miliband , I hope the change in your policy with Hezboallah is a step forward in U.K    glimpse to the middle east . you know that U.K is responsible for establishing Israel , you should know..." Show more »"Mr.David Miliband , I hope the change in your policy with Hezboallah is a step forward in U.K    glimpse to the middle east .

    you know that U.K is responsible for establishing Israel , you should know Mr.David that this disposal is illegal ,because you give land that you don't owned to other one ,you may say Israel (Zionist) have right to establish Israel from history they( Zionist)said that ,ok.
    Arab live in palestine as Canaan (they are arab migrated from Arab peninsula before  2500 B.C ) & Jew occupy Palestine less than 73 years (from 1000B.C that what torah said not me) from 5000 years that history of Palestine.....

    and how Israel estaplish by migrated Palesine people in 1948 they migrated over 4 million palestinies people (that number from UNRWA) & killed many thousands & stolen their land.
    18,147 Palestine home have been demolished since 1976 ...


    i want to give you some idea about what happenig there , you may ask me why you talk about Palestine iam not going to visit Palestine iam going to visit Jordan,,i know that but you know Mr.David here in Jordan we love Palestine because palestinies people are our brothers and you know Mr.David peace in  the middle east & world flow from Palestine....

    finally,iam talk alot but iam don't ask you any question, ok , my question "when U.k change it's idea about arabic resistance ,and stop support Israel & support the right owner ?????"" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. fcoadmin asked David Miliband: "Foreign Secretary David Miliband answers five questions put to him from members of the public in Jordan."
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click 'play' to view."

  1. indiansummer asked David Miliband: "Aren't a lot of the problems in the Middle East and South Asia the result of some English Lord drawing lines on a map in the first half of the twentieth century? how can England get past that legacy?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. indiansummer asked David Miliband: "Good for you for talking to Al Assad. But do you think he'll ever bring democracy to Syria? Is that important these days?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. Londontowner asked David Miliband: "Which foreign leader has suprised you the most since you became Foreign Secretary?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view."

  1. quisquis asked David Miliband: "Hi, I would like to hear your opinion on whether it is not time to abolish the concept of "veto power" in the United Nations Security Council.  NB: I do not believe, that the system of "permanent seats"..." Show more »"Hi,
    I would like to hear your opinion on whether it is not time to abolish the concept of "veto power" in the United Nations Security Council.  NB: I do not believe, that the system of "permanent seats" should be changed, I am only referring to the veto power of the permanent members." Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. sarahsmith23 asked David Miliband: "when obama inevitably takes the u.s to war with pakistan how do you intend to get us out the way?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. markOwen asked David Miliband: "I am currently serving in the armed forces in Catterick. I am on my WO2 education course and have been given an essay on current affairs. The question posed for me to work on is " Will President-elect..." Show more »"I am currently serving in the armed forces in Catterick. I am on my WO2 education course and have been given an essay on current affairs. The question posed for me to work on is " Will President-elect Obama have any infuance over UK forgien policy" 
     I know that we have had strong links with the USA for many years now and if i could recieve any information on what David Milband thinks will happen in the future i would be very greatful and im sure it would be a firt to get a information first hand on my course.

    Thank you for any help you can give

    WO2 Mark Owen" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. Yaseen asked David Miliband: "What is UK doing regarding the criminal activities and war crimes committed by Israel against the people of Gaza. It is a shame on anyone to stay silent, speacially in a position of power like a forign..." Show more »"What is UK doing regarding the criminal activities and war crimes committed by Israel against the people of Gaza.

    It is a shame on anyone to stay silent, speacially in a position of power like a forign minister.

    I want to be able to visit my family, which I am not allowed to, because of the Israeli imposed closure if Gaza, denying them the most basic human rights. It is disgracefull, that you are allowing it to happen while watching silently.

    Regards

    Yasin Abushaban" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. DWilliams71 asked David Miliband: "We won't be able to afford the war in Afghanistan now, will we?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answers."

  1. robins asked David Miliband: "Being an Arsenal fan, what is your opinion on Arsene Wenger's foreign policy - of playing only foreigners I mean?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. the6thestate asked David Miliband: "Do you think the national interests of the four countries of the UK are given equal weighting in UK foreign policy? Can you think of an occasion when their interests might conflict?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. dylanwr asked David Miliband: "I was wondering what would you think of an independent Wales that has a voice in the UN and international affairs but still a part of the United Kingdom?"
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play to view answer."

  1. DJSwansea asked David Miliband: "Have any governments in the last few decades had any bad ideas on Foreign Policy-made any mistakes? I ask because you said something on BBC Wales about the UK having some of the best ideas on foreign ..." Show more »"Have any governments in the last few decades had any bad ideas on Foreign Policy-made any mistakes? I ask because you said something on BBC Wales about the UK having some of the best ideas on foreign policy-presumably we are also good at learning from our mistakes?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. william asked David Miliband: ""With the financial crisis in the UK, will the Govt review its policy on overseas Aid?""
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. jackman asked David Miliband: ""I'm not convinced that the average person cares too much about foreign policy because, by its nature, it doesn't directly affect them. What they do care about I'm sure though is being involved in wars..."..." Show more »" "I'm not convinced that the average person cares too much about foreign policy because, by its nature, it doesn't directly affect them. What they do care about I'm sure though is being involved in wars with other countries -  and on the last occasion this happened with the UK, the majority of british people were clearly against it, yet it went ahead. Will the people be listened to in the future? I'm thinking of the possibility that the USA decides to take military action against Iran and  asks  for our assistance."" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

  1. SharadHarvi asked David Miliband: "In my view the planet is dying of consumption.The next World Climate Summit will take place in Denmark next year and Connie Heddegaard, (Danish Environment Minister) says that this occasion is critical to..." Show more »"In my view the planet is dying of consumption.The next World Climate Summit will take place in Denmark next year and Connie Heddegaard, (Danish Environment Minister) says that this occasion is critical to halt or reduce long term damage to the environment. In the light of the current global economic meltdown, it seems that countries are at last beginning to work together to save their economies and enter into a more cooperative spirit of doing business. Is now an ideal time to build the issue of climate change into the economic rescue package that will not only deal with more efficient ways of creating energy but to drive down the negative effects of the consumer culture the worst of which are eminating from aspiring 3rd world countries like India and China who are about to move into the super-league of economic powers. What plans do the government have to alleviate that?" Show less »
  2. David Miliband answer: "Click "play" to view answer."

12